Alexa can control your TV with a Logitech Harmony. Here's how
I don't need the remote control. When I want to turn on the TV, pause a movie or change the volume, I can just say the magic words aloud.
It wasn't particularly easy to set up, and it didn't come free -- you'll need patience and one of a specific set of pricey Logitech Harmony universal remote controls to get things working. (Even then, you won't be able to ask for everything you can do with a traditional remote.)
Still, controlling my home entertainment system with Amazon's Alexa voice assistant and a Logitech Harmony Hub is one of the coolest things I've done with my smart home. Here are some things I can ask Alexa to do:
Update, July 19: Alexa just made made the Harmony skill way simpler in a software update, so you won't need to add the words "Tell Harmony" to some of your commands. Plus, you'll only need to install a single skill now. Most of this guide still stands, but if you skip down to steps 4 and 5, you'll notice a few differences.
1. Get a Harmony Hub
For starters, you'll need an Amazon Echo or some other gadget with Amazon's Alexa voice assistant built-in. (Cheapest option is the Amazon Echo Dot -- at $50, it's a no-brainer.)
But by itself, the Echo can't control your TV, receiver, or other streaming gadgets. For that, you need a $99 Logitech Harmony Hub, a Wi-Fi equipped puck that lets Echo talk to your TV and other home entertainment products.
Several of Logitech's fancier recent remotes actually come with the Hub, including the Harmony Elite, Pro, Ultimate, Ultimate Home, Ultimate Hub, Home Control, Companion, Smart Keyboard and Smart Control. (They use it as a wireless bridge so you don't have to point your handheld remote directly at the TV, or so you can control everything with your phone.) With a firmware update, Alexa can now send commands to the Hub as well.
But if you don't have the Hub, you'll need to get one. Earlier Logitech products (even the similar-looking Harmony Link) won't work.
Place the Hub close to your home entertainment center, without any major obstacles in the way. Since the Hub fires beams of infrared light in every direction to send its commands, you don't necessarily need a direct line of sight between the Hub and each device. (Mine totally reaches my A/V receiver without.)
But if your devices are inside a closed cabinet, you may need to plug in an additional wired IR blaster (typically included with the Hub) to reach other devices.
2. Program your Harmony
Alexa doesn't know your TV exists unless you tell the Harmony first, so that's what we'll be doing in this step -- telling the Hub how to control your home entertainment system. (We'll add Alexa in step 3.)
Download the Harmony app for iOS or for Android, and follow its prompts -- it should walk you through the steps of pairing the Hub, setting up an account, then adding your entertainment devices and some basic "activities" to get started. If you get lost, here's Logitech's official setup guide.
If you've never used a Harmony before, here's the key thing to understand: instead of asking a specific device what to do, you'll be controlling an activity instead. Harmony combines your devices into activities like "Watch TV," which tells all your devices what to do at the same time.
For instance, when I tell Harmony to "Play Xbox One," it automatically knows to:
Because Harmony uses the same dumb one-way infrared signals as any ol' remote control, it can sometimes get confused -- the Harmony remote doesn't actually know whether something is set properly because it doesn't get feedback from your devices. If your TV takes a while to warm up before the Harmony tells it to switch inputs, for example, you might be left staring at a black screen because the TV wasn't ready to receive the second command.
(Thankfully, you can change the order of Harmony's commands or even add a slight delay to fix that. Go to Settings > Harmony Setup > Add/Edit Devices & Activities > Activities > pick an activity > Edit Start Sequence > Edit Entertainment Devices, then drag to rearrange or Add A Delay if needed.)
And once you add Alexa into the mix, it's going to be really tough to tell why your system didn't work the way you asked. So before you move on to step 3, you'll want to set up and test all the activities you want Alexa to control, which may mean diving through a lot of menus in the Harmony app. Like I said, patience.
For example, your activity list might include:
If you want to ask Alexa to switch to a particular channel (one of the coolest features!) you'll need to prep that in advance with the Harmony app too. Make sure you have a Watch TV activity (this is key), then go Settings > Harmony Setup > Add/Edit Devices & Activities > Favorites. (You'll give each Favorite channel its own voice commands in step 3.)
Pro tip: Jot down which devices are plugged into each of your HDMI ports in advance, so you don't have to go poking around behind your A/V receiver each time the Harmony app needs that info.
3. Prep your Amazon Echo
Now, it's time to add voice commands with Alexa.
First, in case you haven't already figured this out, you may want to physically move your Amazon Echo away from your TV and speakers, and toward your couch. Otherwise, Alexa may not be able to hear you when the TV volume's too loud. You may also need to update your Harmony firmware.
Next, it's time to install the Harmony skill inside the Alexa app on your phone. Go to the Skills tab in the Alexa app, search for Harmony, and pick the "Harmony" skill with the blue logo. Log in with the same account you created for your Harmony.
Why is there a second "Harmony - Inactive" skill with a red logo? Originally you'd need two different Harmony skills to get everything working, but as of July 2017, that's no longer the case.
Before you finish setting up the skill, be sure to spend some time creating "friendly names" for each of the devices and favorite channels you want to control. They're the names that Alexa will recognize when you say them out loud, and you need to do it now -- after this point, you can't change them without reinstalling the whole skill.
You might even want to set up multiple "friendly names" for the same device; that way, it won't matter whether you say "PS4" or "PlayStation" or "Blu-ray player" when you mean the PlayStation 4 each time. It also might help to be able to say "CBS" instead of your local affiliate's four-letter code.
Just know that you may have some trouble finding words that Harmony will accept and Alexa can easily pronounce. For instance, you won't be able to use "Syfy" or "Sci-Fi" to activate the Syfy Channel. "Sci Fi Channel" works, though.
Once your Alexa Harmony skill is synced up, there's one last step: refresh Alexa's list of devices by saying "Alexa, discover devices" aloud, or with the "Discover devices" button in the Smart Home tab of the Alexa app.
4. Take Alexa + Harmony for a spin
You're all set. But what can you actually do with your voice alone? As of July 2017:
Turn on your whole home entertainment center and set it to a specific device, TV channel, or Roku channel:
Change channels (assuming you already used one of the "turn on" commands above)
Mute, raise or lower the volume on your TV or A/V receiver (again, assuming you've already sent a "turn on" command):
Pause, resume, or skip ahead (ditto):
Turn off all your devices after a period of time:
Turn everything off immediately:
Note that while I found the power, volume, mute and sleep timers to be pretty reliable, the playback commands may not work with every device or app. For instance, "skip forward" worked great with a DVD player, but not with a Comcast X1 DVR or any streaming app I tried.
I also found Sony's PlayStation 4 to be particularly finnicky; you can now turn it off with the Harmony Hub, but you need to press a button on the gamepad to turn it on again. And while you can pause and unpause in the PS4's Netflix app, the playback controls don't work with Blu-rays or HBO Go on my PlayStation.
5. Know how to fix things when they break
You may notice that there's no more need to say "Tell Harmony" before some of these commands, and that's great!
But here's the catch: Alexa may forget that you're talking to your entertainment center after a period of time, or if you ask Alexa to start streaming music, or if there's an error. You might find that when you say "Alexa, raise the volume," nothing happens.
At that point, you've got two choices:
After a good half-hour of testing, I'd definitely recommend the latter. I had a pretty tough time getting Alexa to regularly recognize my "Mute my Shield" commands, and I'd like to think I have a pretty clear voice. But whenever I said "Alexa, turn on the Shield," all the voice commands started working immediately after.
And honestly, repeating "Alexa, turn on DEVICE" is the best way to fix anything that goes wrong. If Harmony screws up something simple like setting your receiver to the right input, I've found that if I just repeat the voice command a second time, Alexa and Harmony will almost always nudge the bit that didn't flip into the right position.
Here's what works with the Amazon EchoSee all photos+45 More
Is it really worth it?
There's no question that pairing Alexa and Harmony can be a bit of a hassle, particularly given how much tweaking you may need to do before it can launch complex "let's fire up Netflix on the Roku and dim the lights" sequences reliably with a single voice command. Read my colleague Ry Crist's piece for more about that.
And it's honestly a bit of a shame the world still needs to use aging, dumb, unreliable beams of infrared light to control our home entertainment devices to begin with. It'd be lovely if they could talk to each other automatically by discovering one another on your home network, the same way Alexa can talk to smart light bulbs or your phone can talk to a Chromecast today.
(Don't get me started on HDMI-CEC, the standard that supposedly allows any two HDMI devices to sync up, but was gutted by greedy device manufacturers that each tried to claim it as their own.)
If you don't already have a Harmony Hub, definitely ask yourself how often you'd actually want or need to turn on, off, pause, play, adjust volume and mute, skip forward and backward or switch to a particular activity or channel, hands-free.
My excuse: I've got a newborn daughter, and it's pretty awesome to not miss out on some crucial "Sherlock" dialogue when she suddenly, desperately needs to be changed. And I really love feeling like I'm living in the future. I use it every day.